The National Flag is like a symbol of our Indian identity - that we are
definitely a part of the national whole. Without this we are left as lonely
cronies roaming in the jungle.
****
As an artist, I find the visual aspect of our flag too drab. Whenever I
observed Indian flag flapping alongside the world flags, it makes no visual
impression. The idea is great but without not much artistic involvement.
Incidentally, most of our political symbols are most un-artistic. Our flag
is but a major evidence.
****
There are two sides of culture, popular and conceptual. Popular culture
expresses the ordinary demands that can easily be manipulated such as in
politics, riots, religions or, say, fashion. In India normally we do not
trivialize the national flag, but the waves of market-culture from the West,
especially the U.S., have blinded the urban taste.
Amitabh Sen Gupta, artist
While I certainly prefer to see the tricolour to seeing an orange or a
green flag, I do believe that in the 21st century human beings have to move
beyond narrow nationalism and embrace the fact that we are all human beings
first.
Anand Patwardhan, filmmaker
I certainly welcome the fact that all citizens are empowered to use the
flag, but certain self-restrain is necessary. I can't see an undergarment
being made out of a flag, for example. If the citizens can't, then the
government should lay down the norms.
****
The association of flag colours with specific religions has become part of
public consciousness only in the recent years, largely due to the communal
strife. The coming together of colours representing the different religions
as seen in the flag is therefore a welcome idea.
Anjolie Ela Menon, artist
I had done two portraits for newspapers that involved the National-Flag one
of which was done more than ten years back. It was of Manmohan Singh when he
was the Finance Minister and I provided an opening in our flag to suggest
how the Indian society was being opened up to MNCs. In 1997, a magazine did
a cover feature in which they had Jaya Bachchan, Leela Samson and myself
dressed in saris matching the different colours of the flag. We were
photographed in a visual composition based on an Amrita Sher Gil painting.
The idea was to highlight the changing place of Indian women over the fifty
years since independence.
Aparna Caur, artist
National-Flag is not always hoisted out of patriotic sentiments. It can be
a matter of safety. Fishermen operating in places where India shares a
maritime border with Pakistan or Bangladesh, hoist the tricolour on their
boats to avoid needless harassment from the Indian coast guards.
Arvind Chudasama, animator
There may be religious symbols, flags etc. but the National-Flag has its
own identity and is quite distinct and we must show due respect to it
separate from other religious flags and symbols. It should command our due
respect.
Asghar Ali Engineer, scholar and activist
What has been the underlying spirit that the Indian flag symbolizes?
- Fraternity in liberty rather than untrammeled pursuit of individual
happiness.
- Fraternity through justice rather than justice as equality in mediocrity.
- Diversity and unity rather than diversity by itself or unity by itself.
- Panchsheel in relation to the rest of the world rather than any dream of
world hegemony.
Into that heaven let our country awake.
Prof. Ashok R. Kelkar, linguist
I was approaching 17 when India was to be free. But no celebrations in
Nizam's Secunderabad where I lived then. I used to bicycle to Sultan Bazaar
in Hyderabad and once saw a police station enveloped by a huge tree. So if
one could climb the tree unnoticed, he could go to the terrace of the police
station. The police station was the place to fly the Indian flag! There was
an old tricolour in our house. It had a charka, not a chakra. But still good
enough as a symbol of a free Indian nation. For a week I dreamed of getting
to the place, climbing the tree, etc. But where was I to keep my bicycle?
Hyderabad was more than ten kilometers away and I didn't know any people
there. It was all just a young boy's dreamy heroics.
But in truth, somebody did plant the Indian flag atop the Sultan Bazaar
police station, and when the authorities discovered it, the whole city did
become very hot. People who publicly clamoured for the merger of the
princely state with the Indian Union were hunted and jailed. Ultimately, the
merger took place - thirteen months later.
Ashokamitran, writer
To see poor, malnourished and marginalized young people carrying the flag
of the nation that has betrayed their promise is an experience that
invariably fills me with guilt and sadness. The flag then becomes a symbol
of promises broken and trust betrayed. Let me hope that the next generation
will be more worthy than this one of our flag and what it should mean for
every citizen.
Ashoke Chatterjee, crafts and design specialist
The tricolour is a symbol of our freedom, of our self-respect, and of
sacrifices and martyrdoms. People belonging to the older generations would
certainly remember the time when young boys and girls would form themselves
into small groups, take the flag in their hands, and go around villages and
city streets singing vijayi vishwa tiranga pyara, jhanda uncha rahe hamara
(may our beloved and victorious tricolour fly high in the world).
Atal Behari Vajpayee